Why the Decline in Student Interest for the Geo (Earth) Sciences ?
We ask Grok? Why the Decline in Student Interest for the Geo (Earth) Sciences ?
Geosciences (encompassing fields like geology, geophysics, and Earth sciences) have experienced a steady global decline in student enrollment over the past decade, with particularly sharp drops in the U.S., Canada, UK, and Australia. For instance, U.S. undergraduate enrollment peaked at around 32,000 students in 2015 but fell to just over 20,000 by 2021, a roughly 37% decrease.
Graduate programs have seen even steeper declines, dropping 27% in the 2019-2020 academic year alone. This trend has led to shrinking departments, program mergers, and even closures at some universities. While the decline predates the COVID-19 pandemic, external shocks like the pandemic and economic cycles have accelerated it. Below, I outline the key reasons based on analyses from geoscience organizations, academic studies, and educator reports.
Table 1: Key Reasons for Fewer Students Studying Geosciences.
|
Factor |
Description |
Examples/Evidence |
|
Economic Ties to Volatile Industries |
Enrollments historically fluctuate with oil and gas prices and private investment in mining/extraction. Low energy prices and layoffs reduce perceived job stability, deterring students. |
U.S. enrollment mirrors oil/gas extraction budgets; sharp drops followed the 2014-2016 oil crash and 2020 lows. Traditional petroleum-focused tracks have seen the steepest declines. |
|
Shift to "Greener" or "Futuristic" Fields |
Students increasingly opt for environmental science, climatology, oceanography, atmospheric sciences, or planetary geology, viewing them as more aligned with climate action and innovation. Geoscience's association with fossil fuels creates a stigma. |
Resource-related geosciences (e.g., oil/gas) down sharply; environmental tracks up. In Texas universities, students prioritize "sustainable" options over traditional geology. |
|
Limited Early Exposure and Recruitment |
Geoscience is underrepresented in K-12 curricula, with minimal hands-on learning or visibility. Universities struggle with outreach, and the field is seen as "old-fashioned" or irrelevant compared to biology or computer science. |
UK enrollment halved post-1988 curriculum reforms reducing geology exposure. U.S. high schoolers report low awareness; geoscientists criticized for poor public communication. |
|
Perceived Difficulty and Broader STEM Challenges |
Rigorous requirements (e.g., calculus, physics, field work) deter students, especially Gen Z facing mental health strains. Overall natural science enrollment is declining amid urban lifestyles and less "real Nature" exposure. |
COVID-19 exacerbated dropout risks; declining male enrollment (historically dominant in geosciences) ties to broader U.S. college trends. Media portrays nature as fragile, pushing students to ecology over geology. |
|
Globalization and External Shocks |
International students, once a buffer, now attend local universities. The pandemic caused a 10% undergraduate enrollment drop in 2019-2020, with remote learning hurting field-based disciplines. |
Enrollment down across Global North; UK's MSc programs fell 6% from 2018-2021, with further drops in 2022. |
Potential Paths Forward
To reverse this, experts recommend rebranding programs (e.g., emphasizing Earth sciences and climate resilience), boosting K-12 integration, targeted recruitment for underrepresented groups (e.g., women and minorities, who now make up a growing but still small share), and highlighting diverse careers beyond oil/gas, like hazard mitigation and renewable energy.
Some U.S. departments have stabilized by merging with environmental programs, and Australia's enrollment ticked up slightly post-2020 due to critical minerals demand. This trend risks a workforce shortage, as geoscience jobs (projected to grow 5% by 2031 in the U.S.) outpace graduates. If you're a student or educator, resources like the American Geosciences Institute offer recruitment toolkits.
The Know Your H20 Team - Thoughts on the Subject
- Failure in the K - 12 education program - failing to educate students in basic sciences, math, english, history, and civics has created a culture of young adults that are not really interested in seeking truth or an understanding of the world. Step 1: Bring back the requirement for the SAT exams. Step 2. Support programs that fund the student and not the school district.
- Ideology - On many levels social and political ideology has replaced the scientific method and we are teaching the children the ethics of the ends justifies the means. We are training social justice warriors and community organizers that promote climate change when they really know nothing about earth sciences, scientific method, or basic science. Support school choice and charter schools.
- STEM programs that have not focused on the Earth Sciences.
- Entry Level: Increase the number of entry level positions and encourage mentoring programs. There is not a lot of outreach in the K - 12 or even the 9 - 12 education programs.
- We need to figure out ways to help to reduce cost of the education programs, especially in the Earth Sciences and we need to promote education savings programs.
- Based on the most recent 2024–2025 data from surveys, college applications, Google search trends, YouTube/TikTok career content, and direct conversations with high school students (especially Gen Z and early Gen Alpha), here are the careers that today’s teens are actually aspiring to or seriously exploring — ranked roughly by popularity/interest level. (Our we really giving these kids good advice). I am happy to see the trades and nursing in the top 10, but "Influencer". (asked Grok)
|
Rank |
Career / Path |
Why It’s Hot Right Now (2024–2025) |
Typical Student Profile |
|
1 |
Software Engineering / AI & Machine Learning |
High salaries ($120k–$200k+ starting), remote work, “future-proof,” heavy TikTok/YouTube hype (e.g., “$500k out of college” videos) |
Strong in math/CS, self-taught coders, competitive kids aiming for FAANG or startups |
|
2 |
Content Creator / Influencer / YouTuber / Streamer |
Dream of “being famous & rich while playing games or posting skits”; MrBeast-style success stories dominate |
Creative, extroverted, often willing to delay or skip college |
|
3 |
Nursing / Healthcare (PA, PT, Nurse Anesthetist) |
Job security, good pay ($100k–$300k for advanced roles), “meaningful work,” post-COVID respect for healthcare |
Empathetic students, strong science grades, many girls |
|
4 |
Entrepreneurship / “Start my own business” (e-commerce, dropshipping, agency, SaaS) |
Inspired by TikTok gurus and “laptop lifestyle”; want freedom & unlimited upside |
Hustle culture kids, often boys, big on side hustles already |
|
5 |
Medicine (Doctor – especially dermatology, anesthesiology, surgery) |
Still prestigious and lucrative, but fewer students than 10 years ago because of 10–15 years of schooling |
Top 5–10% academically, immigrant-family pressure common |
|
6 |
Finance / Investment Banking / Private Equity / Quant Trading |
Wall Street money, prestige at elite schools, TikTok finance bros |
Ivy/target school hopefuls, math/econ strong |
|
7 |
Data Science / Data Analyst |
Seen as “easier” entry into tech than pure coding, good pay, lots of bootcamps |
Math/statistics kids who don’t love pure programming |
|
8 |
Trades (Electrician, Plumber, HVAC, Welding) – huge surge |
$80k–$150k with little debt, “trade school > college” movement on social media, labor shortages |
Hands-on learners tired of “college is the only way” narrative |
|
9 |
Psychology → Therapist / Psychiatrist |
Mental health awareness boom, desire to help others |
Empathetic, good listeners, many girls |
|
10 |
Cybersecurity / Ethical Hacking |
“Cool” factor, high demand, good pay, certifications instead of degree possible |
Gamers & tinkerers who like puzzles and breaking things |
|
11 |
Aerospace / Mechanical Engineering (often SpaceX/Tesla inspired) |
Elon Musk effect, rockets & EVs are exciting |
Physics/math nerds |
|
12 |
Film / Cinematography / Video Editing |
Everyone makes TikToks; dream of Hollywood or working with big creators |
Artsy & techy combo |
|
13 |
Law (especially corporate or IP/tech law) |
Money + arguing on the internet translates well |
Debate team kids, strong writers |
|
14 |
Military → Officer (or ROTC for free college) |
Full ride + benefits, respect, adventure |
Patriotic or pragmatic students |
|
15 |
Teaching (surprisingly rising again, especially STEM & special ed shortages) |
Loan forgiveness programs, desire for stable & meaningful career |
Service-minded students |
Notable Trends Among 2024–2025 High Schoolers
- Massive shift away from traditional “safe” degrees (accounting, marketing, biology) unless they lead to clear high-paying roles.
- Huge interest in paths with little or no student debt (trades, CS (computer science ?) self-taught, military, certain healthcare roles).
- “Portfolio > Degree” mindset — many plan to build GitHubs, YouTube channels, or businesses in high school. (Is more of the website designers degrees gone wrong?)
- Girls dominate interest in healthcare & psychology; boys dominate CS (computer science ?), finance, trades, and content creation (???).
- Medicine and law are still desired but seen as “too long / too much debt” by many average students.
We are trying to do our part.
Mentoring - How I Became a Water Professional and I love my career ?
Our Newest Educational Booklet - The Soils Guide.
Our Blog Sites - Many Topics
- Advice
- earth sciences
- Environment
- environmental careers
- Environmental Education
- geology
- geosciences
- jobs
- mentoring
- Professional
- soil science
- STEM